Choosing the Right Schools in Windermere, FL: What Parents Need to Know

Windermere, FL, where the right home means being close to great schoolsIt’s easy to be drawn in by lakefront views, elegant architecture, and well-manicured streets when looking for a new home in Windermere, FL. However, for many families, there is one non-negotiable factor: access to quality schools.

In Windermere, FL—a picturesque town set along the Butler Chain of Lakes—you’ll find a range of top-rated schools. They’re a cornerstone of community life and a driver of long-term home value.

If you’re planning on moving to this part of the Sunshine State, we’ll explore the area’s leading educational options, highlight their academic strengths, and their connection to the local housing market to help you make an informed decision regarding your next home.

How Schools Affect Home Values in Windermere

In Windermere, FL, school zones often play a major role in property value. While buyers with children prioritize access to top-performing schools, even those without kids recognize the long-term investment potential of a strong district.

Homes located within sought-after school zones typically command higher prices and attract more competitive offers. This sustained demand can drive steady property appreciation over time, making schools a key factor in smart homebuying decisions.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a School in Windermere

The right school can shape a child’s academic journey and overall development. When comparing options, a few key factors can help guide the decision:

• Academic & Extracurricular Programs – Robust offerings in STEM, arts, athletics, and languages help enrich learning and encourage social growth.
• Class Size & Teacher Ratios – Smaller classes allow for more personalized instruction. Reviewing average class sizes and faculty credentials provides insight into the learning environment.
• College Prep & Advanced Courses – For older students, look at available AP, honors, or dual enrollment programs, as well as graduation and college acceptance rates.
• Parental Involvement & School Culture – A strong school community with active parent engagement and open communication often leads to a more supportive atmosphere. Visiting in person can offer a valuable perspective.
• Partner with a Local Agent – A Windermere-based agent can help you target listings in high-demand school zones and act fast when new homes for sale in Windermere, FL hit the market.
• Act Quickly – Homes near top schools move fast. Being pre-approved and offer-ready increases your chances in a competitive market.

Public Schools in Windermere, FL

There are schools in Windermere, FL that utilize the most innovative teaching methodsFamilies moving to Windermere often choose the area for its high-performing public schools under the Orange County Public Schools (OCPS) umbrella. One of the largest and most diverse districts in the country, OCPS is known for academic excellence and forward-thinking programs, with the district having earned an “A” grade from the Florida Department of Education as well as national recognition for narrowing achievement gaps and raising overall student performance.

If you are planning to make Windermere, FL your new home, here are some of the public schools you may want to consider:

• Windermere High School – Serving grades 9–12, Windermere High is a modern campus with a reputation for both academic rigor and school spirit. Students can pursue AP and International Baccalaureate (IB) coursework, and the school has a strong graduation rate and high college matriculation. Beyond academics, it fields competitive athletic teams and offers dozens of student-run clubs, from business to performing arts.
• Bridgewater Middle School – Bridgewater Middle is a hub for STEM-minded students, offering advanced math, science, and technology classes that prep students for high school success. The school encourages exploration through hands-on programs like robotics, science fairs, and digital design. Extracurriculars range from band to academic teams, fostering a well-rounded experience.
• Horizon West Middle School – This newer school in the heart of a growing community prides itself on diversity, inclusivity, and a strong academic track record. Horizon West’s forward-thinking approach includes integrated arts and digital learning tools. The school also emphasizes student voice and leadership through advisory programs and cultural initiatives.
• Windermere Elementary School – With a consistently strong GreatSchools rating, Windermere Elementary blends academic achievement with community connection. It hosts popular family events, active PTO involvement, and enrichment programs that extend learning beyond the classroom.
• Keene’s Crossing Elementary School – Praised for its low student-teacher ratio and engaged faculty, Keene’s Crossing provides a supportive environment where each child is known by name. The school offers differentiated instruction and a strong reading culture, as well as enrichment through music, art, and physical education.
• Sunset Park Elementary School – A favorite for young families, Sunset Park builds foundational skills through research-based early education practices. Teachers prioritize literacy and emotional development while offering early STEM exposure and exploratory play.
• Bay Lake Elementary School – Bay Lake fosters creativity and curiosity through innovative learning experiences such as project-based learning, garden education, and interactive technology. The school’s modern facilities and commitment to individualized instruction create a dynamic learning space.

Private & Charter Schools in Windermere, FL

While many of Windermere’s public schools are highly rated, some families may seek private or charter education for their benefits, such as smaller class sizes, faith-based instruction, or specialized academics.

Here are some Windermere, FL private schools you may want to consider:

• Windermere Preparatory School – As one of Central Florida’s premier private institutions, Windermere Prep serves students from Pre-K through grade 12 with a globally focused curriculum anchored by the IB Diploma Programme. Students benefit from individualized learning, small class sizes, and state-of-the-art facilities—including a lakeside arts center and athletic complex. Graduates often matriculate to top-tier universities, and the campus culture emphasizes intellectual curiosity, leadership, and global citizenship.
• The First Academy – A top Christian college-prep school, The First Academy blends faith and academics across grades K–12. Students are encouraged to lead lives of purpose, whether through championship-caliber athletics, robust fine arts, or service projects. With a strong alumni network and high college acceptance rates, the school offers a mission-driven education in a supportive, values-oriented setting.
• Foundation Academy – Foundation Academy offers a holistic, Christ-centered education for students from kindergarten through high school Known for its close-knit community and leadership focus, the school integrates faith with academics and extracurriculars. Students engage in everything from competitive sports to chapel services, leadership retreats, and service learning. Multiple campuses across the area provide flexibility for families.
• Premier Academy – Catering to early learners and K–8 students, Premier Academy prides itself on intimate class sizes, personalized instruction, and a strong focus on early childhood development. With a nurturing environment and hands-on curriculum, Premier supports students’ academic growth and emotional well-being, laying the foundation for a lifelong love of learning.

Find Your Perfect Windermere Home

No matter where you choose to put down roots in Windermere, FL, you’ll be close to exceptional schools and vibrant neighborhoods.

Thinking of making the move? I’d love to help you every step of the way. I’m Alexis Bress, a top-producing Central Florida Realtor with a passion for matching families with their perfect home.

Ready to get started? Call me at 407.900.0771 or send me an email to schedule your personalized consultation.